| Children |
| | 1. Sarah Brotherton Vail, b. 9 Mar 1827, Canandaigna, NY [Natural] |
| | 2. Mary Vail, b. 13 Oct 1828, Canandaigna, NY [Natural] |
| | 3. Mercy Vail, b. 27 Mar 1830, Canandaigna, NY [Natural] |
| | 4. William Brotherton Vail, b. 21 Nov 1831, Ontario County, NY [Natural] |
| | 5. Ann Vail, b. 21 Sep 1833, Farmington, NY [Natural] |
| | 6. Grace Ware Vail, b. 17 Jul 1836, Farmington, NY [Natural] |
| | 7. David Willson Vail, b. 21 Apr 1838, Farmington, NY [Natural] |
| | 8. Katherine Louisa Vail, b. 2 Apr 1839, Farmington, NY [Natural] |
| | 9. John Vail, b. 15 Aug 1840 [Natural] |
| | 10. Augusta Eliza Vail, b. 23 Nov 1841 [Natural] |
| | 11. Richard Brotherton Vail, b. 3 Apr 1844 [Natural] |
|