| Children |
| | 1. Elizabeth P. Morningstar, b. 15 Nov 1851, Willoughby Township, Ontario , d. 25 Feb 1913, Buffalo, NY (Age 61 years) [Natural] |
| | 2. Esther Morningstar, b. 16 Apr 1852, Willoughby Township, Ontario , d. 13 Aug 1931, Fairview Cemetery, Niagara Falls, Ontario (Age 79 years) [Natural] |
| | 3. Reuben Morningstar, b. 12 Mar 1854, Willoughby Township, Ontario , d. 24 Jan 1922, Willoughby Cemetery (Age 67 years) [Natural] |
| | 4. Rebecca Morningstar, b. 1857 [Natural] |
| | 5. Louis B. Morningstar, b. 16 Nov 1860, Willoughby Township, Ontario , d. 21 Feb 1899, Buffalo, NY-buried Willoughby Township, Ontario (Age 38 years) [Natural] |
| | 6. George Gabriel Morningstar, b. 25 Jul 1865, Willoughby Township, Ontario , d. 14 May 1912, St. John's Cemetery, Snyder, Ontario (Age 46 years) [Natural] |
| | 7. Catherine (Katie) Morningstar, b. 14 Mar 1866, d. 13 Aug 1918, St. John's Cemetery, Snyder, Ontario (Age 52 years) [Family member] |
| | 8. William Morningstar, b. 1869 [Natural] |
| | 9. Aaron Morningstar, b. 7 Oct 1869, Willoughby Township, Ontario [Natural] |
|