| Children |
| | 1. Elias Morningstar, b. 15 Aug 1834, d. 10 Jul 1863, Overholt Cemetery (Age 28 years) [Natural] |
| | 2. Sarah Ann Morningstar, b. 7 Feb 1836, Bertie Township, Welland, Ontario , d. 4 Feb 1911, Dungannon, Huron County, Ontario (Age 74 years) [Unknown] |
| | 3. Delia Morningstar, b. 28 Apr 1837, d. 17 Nov 1912, Dawn Township, Ontario (Age 75 years) [Natural] |
| | 4. Salome Morningstar, b. 2 Jul 1839 [Natural] |
| | 5. Elisha (Elijah) Morningstar, b. 4 Mar 1841, Humberstone Township, Ontario , d. 8 Jan 1918, Wainfleet Township, Morgan's Point Cemetery (Age 76 years) [Natural] |
| | 6. Simeon Morningstar, b. 25 Dec 1842 [Natural] |
| | 7. Benjamin Morningstar, b. 9 Nov 1844, Ontario , d. Bef 1910 (Age < 65 years) [Natural] |
| | 8. Mary Margaret Morningstar, b. 24 Aug 1846, d. 25 Nov 1853 (Age 7 years) [Natural] |
| | 9. Peter Josepheus Morningstar, b. 14 May 1848, Welland, Ontario , d. 1899, Fort Erie, Ontario (Age 50 years) [Natural] |
| | 10. Priscilla C. Morningstar, b. 5 Jun 1850, Bertie Township, Ontario [Natural] |
| | 11. Daniel Ozias Morningstar, b. 17 Apr 1852 [Natural] |
| | 12. Franklin Ormiston Morningstar, b. 13 Jul 1854, New German, Ontario , d. 1944, Jamestown, NY-buried Fluvanna, NY (Age 89 years) [Natural] |
| | 13. Esther Ella Morningstar, b. 14 Dec 1857, NY , d. North Tonawanda, NY [Natural] |
| | 14. Allan Whitmer Morningstar, b. 14 Jun 1864 [Natural] |
|