| Children |
| | 1. Sylvester Underhill, b. 9 Mar 1825, d. 11 Mar 1909 (Age 84 years) [Natural] |
| | 2. James Underhill, b. 2 Feb 1827 [Natural] |
| | 3. Elizabeth Underhill, b. 16 Oct 1829 [Natural] |
| | 4. Samuel Underhill, b. 15 Sep 1831, Charlotteville Township, Norfolk County [Natural] |
| | 5. Rachel Underhill, b. 24 Sep 1833 [Natural] |
| | 6. Mary Ann Underhill, b. 15 Aug 1836, d. 3 Apr 1923 (Age 86 years) [Natural] |
| | 7. Isabell Underhill, b. 21 Sep 1839 [Natural] |
| | 8. Jasper Underhill, b. 26 Aug 1841, d. 19 Feb 1930, Niagara Falls, Ontario (Age 88 years) [Natural] |
|