| | 1. Susannah Witmer, b. 1833 [Natural] |
| | 2. Mary Witmer, b. 1834 [Natural] |
| | 3. Joseph Witmer, b. 1835 [Natural] |
| | 4. Abraham Witmer, b. 1837 [Natural] |
| | 5. Anna Witmer, b. 1837 [Natural] |
| | 6. John Witmer, b. 1838 [Natural] |
| | 7. Hannah Witmer, b. 1840 [Natural] |
| | 8. Isaac Witmer, b. 1842 [Natural] |
| | 9. Catherine Witmer, b. 1844 [Natural] |
| | 10. Benjamin Witmer, b. 1845, d. 1942 (Age 97 years) [Natural] |
| | 11. Henry Witmer, b. 1847 [Natural] |
| | 12. Samuel Witmer, b. 1849 [Natural] |
| | 13. Sarah Witmer, b. 1851 [Natural] |
| | 14. Aaron Witmer, b. 1854 [Natural] |
| | 15. Moses Witmer, b. 1856 [Natural] |